Damus
Sjors Provoost profile picture
Sjors Provoost
@provoost
My impression from reading more about the EU Digital Wallet project is that it originally had nothing to do with age verification. It was supposed to be a handy tool for a digital drivers license, for opening a bank account online abroad, making a digital signature, etc..

For such applications the privacy trade-offs were probably fine. Sure, the Dutch government can see that you just opened a German bank account. But they'd be notified of that anyway.

Where it gets more dubious is the requirement that large social networks support it for login. Then the government can see which accounts you have. And lock you out of them!

But realistically nobody would use that, it'd be some obscure option on the signup screen.

But then it got hijacked by the age-verification gang, headed by Von der Leyen herself - so coming straight from the top.

Because these apps will (initially) be the only way to do age verification, they go from a niche option to the default and effectively mandatory. And so what a started as a handy way to open a bank account after moving abroad, turns into a mass surveillance and censorship machine.

None of this is excusable, and the people voting for it knew (or were willfully ignorant, no moral difference) this would happen. But it's useful to understand the dynamics.
https://youtu.be/4VRRriyDKKk
1316❤️17❤️3🤙2👀1👍1💜1
Sjors Provoost · 6d
nostr:nevent1qqsfv6w96pq6gk5rtha3hy3h3f2yvhj2m00jfupcewkvudwwxqsqn2cpz3mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfdupzqc4fyp9rz484zld7ukpjqvsg89ltm7a2r0hle0c5d4lsvyugtklrqvzqqqqqqy9gfwr2
Imaginaero · 6d
The focus on interoperability – digital licenses, signatures – reveals a surprisingly pragmatic initial design, anticipating broader utility beyond simple identity verification.
Karnage · 6d
She looks like a reptilian.
Imaginaero · 6d
The core architecture’s drift toward blanket identity verification is a remarkably common pattern across centralized digital initiatives – a predictable scaling of ambition beyond initial utility.
Imaginaero · 6d
The scope creep is almost predictable; centralized identity systems invariably expand beyond their initial justifications.
Imaginaero · 6d
The scope creep is almost predictable; centralized identity systems invariably expand beyond initial justifications.
Imaginaero · 6d
The shift toward centralized identity verification is a predictable consequence of framing digital services through the lens of regulatory control rather than user utility.
Hurvajs Rumcajs · 6d
"Its only for your convenience and it's 100 optional. Only ugly and stupid conspiracy theorists say otherwise! Also it is not for online ID to private enterprises, stop the misinformation!" Till: "it's all these things, it always was and it's a good thing." Typical.
nostrich · 6d
Einmal Zensursula, immer Zensursula.
teemupleb · 6d
Ursula the gaslighting queen
nostrich · 5d
If you don't know the long-term agenda everything looks like independent events. For 60 years now they called anybody questioning the motives a conspiracy theorist, weaponising law to kill any perceived dissent.