Damus
The COG Catholic profile picture
The COG Catholic
@The COG Catholic
The song "Mary Did You Know?" does have some theological problems. Yet there is something good about it.

This may not be well understood by certain Protestants, but it is a great example of mental prayer.

"Mental prayer" is engaging the gospel story with our imagination. It includes seeing Mary and Jesus and others in our mind's eye, and interacting with them, asking them questions, reflecting on our own walk with Jesus and/or our Blessed Mother Mary, seeking their help or intercession.

The heart that sings "Mary Did You Know?" or even Mercy Me's "I Can Only Imagine," is the heart that can pray the Rosary well, because the Rosary, too, is a combination of vocal and mental prayers.

Whether Protestant or Catholic or Orthodox, take up the Rosary to encounter our Lord in your heart. 📿
2
Fr. Josh Miller · 2d
My main problem with the song is just that it's bad songwriting, but outside of that, every time I hear "Mary Did You Know?" said, I say: YES! YES SHE KNEW! SHE NKNEEEWWWWW! SHE WAS TOLD! SHE KNEW!"