Damus
jsr profile picture
jsr
@jsr
Most folks don't love security theater & everyone has had a bad time at a screening checkpoint.

So, let's think for a second about hypothetical private-#TSA companies.

I'd expect them to gravitate towards AI-assigned individual risk ratings to minimize the cost of hiring & training people to interact with travelers.

To create ratings, I'd expect them to demand & consolidate invasive pools of our biometrics, web browsing, commenting, purchasing, movements & private lives.

Just don't call it a "social credit score"

You can bet they'll pivot to trying to monetize their data.

2026: We're a terminal security company
2029: We're a person rating company

Would these ratings make their way into other parts of our lives & things we want to visit?

And who exactly would stand up for us when the ratings are wrong? Or our data is shipped to foreign buyers.

Who holds #PrivateTSA companies accountable? The US doesn't have strong #privacy protections...

I'm also not optimistic about private sector security companies' ability to stop breaches. History backs me up here.

But I do expect that private-TSA companies could use lobbying to limit oversight & accountability.

That's been the history of other privacy-invasive tech companies.

So, as an airline security privatization conversation kicks off, remember that it can't just be "current thing is bad" but needs to consider what kind of future we're inviting in.
2912❤️21🤙5👀2💜2🧡2❤️1
ODELL · 68w
interesting thought experiment i support abolishing the tsa and then we can figure out how to deal with whatever comes next
zeph · 68w
Appreciate this line of thinking
Sophia · 68w
If private, the likelihood of accountability is much lower due to lack of transparency, except for shareholder needs or if corporate social responsibility is in place at the org, which considers society at large. Or if someone speaks truth to power, but with a giant, giant megaphone i.e media 📣 T...
Deleted Account · 68w
These are all good points
metadavid · 68w
ZK-proofs 👀
DefiantDandelion · 68w
1) The TSA is about 20 years old, eliminating them only means going back about 20 years. They didn’t need your chat history or biometrics 25 years ago they don’t need it now. 2) No data besides biometrics are required to authenticate the person is who they say they are from your list. If that’...
DrDanielHodl · 68w
Why not just let the airlines keep their own planes safe?
mrclownworld · 68w
TSA was also created to solve a fake problem. 9/11 was fake. Al-qaeda was fake. This is all so tiresome.
₿oniz23⚡️🏴‍☠️🇮🇹 · 68w
Hi john 😉🤟🏴‍☠️ nice to meet you 🤝 You raise a crucial point criticizing existing systems is easy, but we need to think critically about the alternatives we create. A privatized TSA might remove some of the inefficiencies of government bureaucracy, but it could also introduce an ent...
DeusVult · 68w
VERY well said
ne cede · 68w
Horrible take. The state has no incentive to make the process better for the consumer. You’ve created a number of straw men arguments to suggest that the state can do it better. Why wouldn’t the tsa also resort to the methods described? The tsa is violating the 4th amendment with every passenger...
btconboard #LNHANCE or #CTV · 68w
The TSA is a jobs program disguised as a security apparatus
chris · 68w
TSA as it stands today is a downward spiral of handholding grown adults disguised as protection. The utter dehumanization felt at airports is akin to cattle being farmed to slaughter, then released on good behavior. “Strip down, put your hands up, and shut up” sounds more like a totalitarian p...
cloud69heartless · 68w
lol airport security was always private until relatively recently, and still is in other countries, and it has always worked fine. da TSA is an orwellian nightmare nobody likes created to solve nonexistent problems. the ignorance of dese basic facts is even more orwellian and creepy... either dat or...