Some thoughts
1. bip345 introduced a new utxo which is new, unprecedented, and not in a minor scope. Change is Too big.
2. bip345 seeks fast activation, and inevitable activation, but after only o...
1. The change is much smaller than other soft forms and is a well-scoped change (vs a large sweeping change). It does not introduce new utxos. It introduces new ways to encumber coins
2. The activation for bip345 is currently unspecified. It is not seeking a one month activation.
3. Im not sure what you mean about the other lock time. What are the downsides you want to have discussed?
4. I disagree. OP_VAULT would let individual HODLers massively upgrade their security without a lot of operational complexity. Individual users could have a single phone wallet or hardware wallet that implements a vault and falls back to more complex recovery paths. So you could have the ease of use of something like blue wallet but the theft resistance of a multisig
2. The activation for bip345 is currently unspecified. It is not seeking a one month activation.
3. Im not sure what you mean about the other lock time. What are the downsides you want to have discussed?
4. I disagree. OP_VAULT would let individual HODLers massively upgrade their security without a lot of operational complexity. Individual users could have a single phone wallet or hardware wallet that implements a vault and falls back to more complex recovery paths. So you could have the ease of use of something like blue wallet but the theft resistance of a multisig
1
