the left

Left Purely off gut reaction

Right.

Right. Straight forward, no frills, rough yet appreciative. Sandpaper texture wrapping, nice touch.

I'm late to the party but love tallow. So 100% the one on the right--I would buy this, and will, if you ship to Australia. I would not buy the one on the left. Signed, Christopher The Carnivore 🥩

I like the packaging on the right. 🤗

nostr:nprofile1qqsgydql3q4ka27d9wnlrmus4tvkrnc8ftc4h8h5fgyln54gl0a7dgspxdmhxue69uhkuamr9ec8y6tdv9kzumn9wshkz7tkdfkx26tvd4urqctvxa4ryur3wsergut9vsch5dmp8peszrthwden5te0dehhxtnvdakqtxjx6r like this soaps bro 🧼 👏🤩 nostr:nprofile1qqsppdnxpjc82jlm3yn9gawhv7p4nm69a3f80rg5ycw305xned2s0hcpz4mhxue69...

For a handcrafted, premium feel, go with the left (Rustic Tallow). The right is more utilitarian but less distinct.

Actually this looks like front and back to me, but I'm probably just #weird

Left

Soap miner logo from the left, on the right setup. Same with the sticker. 🤙🏽 Do you make hair products too “shampoo”?

I prefer right

I like the right, more manly looking if you are going for that.

The one on the right for sure

Left one!

Right. No doubt

I prefer the color of the paper on the right and how the font works with it. Not opposed to images but would need to see how it works with that.

Right

I'm female, I like the one on the right. The aesthetic matches the product better

Left is more visually interesting IMO

Uncircumcised tallow

Right

R

Right

I prefer the name on the right but thing a small logo would benefit it's credibility.

I’m draw to the left because it has color. Both are good!

The left is great. I’d like your picture to be a bit bigger. It’s clean and bougie.

The problem with the one on the right is that it looks like it could be from anywhere/anyone. The one on the left just needs a bigger logo.

Im a fan of the packaging on the left. Feels more organic and visually appealing. I also like having your graphic for brand familiarity, definitely a premium product feel.

Left

Left

I like Tallow best, increase the font size. Use the Soap Miner sticker on the back an simplify the branding. Good luck with your business.

Left one