This logic is deeply flawed. There are consequences to every choice, and you are free to choose, but not every choice is a good choice. Choosing to make a bad choice doesn't mean you aren't free to choose, it means you don't recognize the difference between good and bad and respect it. "Do not be deceived, God is not mocked. Whatever a man sows, that shall he also reap."
If you choose evil, you reap evil.
If you choose good, you reap good.
Since there is only one true God, if you freely choose to reject Him, and therefore center yourself upon something else, you are choosing to deceive yourself, and therefore reap according to your free choice, and God honors your choice even if he doesn't agree.