Damus
silverpill profile picture
silverpill
@silverpill
I've been reviewing the new FEP from the Mastodon team today, and one thing that caught my attention is the use of Accept and Reject activities for managing approvals. Another day, someone proposed to use Follow activity for "watching a thread".

So now, when you receive a standard activity, you need to use increasingly complicated heuristics to figure out what the activity does, because it is not possible to infer that from its type anymore.

This has to stop. I think we need to start giving our activities better names.

#ActivityPub
4
julian · 4w
I see this from the other direction — I think it's great that we have a unified vocabulary for approvals and rejections. Why would we need a separate FeaturedItemAccept when Accept will do nicely? From a code organization perspective it's as complicated as you make it. For the more overloaded acti...
marius · 4w
nostr:nprofile1qy2hwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnyd968gmewwp6kyqpqdf0nthpgzfmvxrzj0cfypmmt45l0y770j260auqhm3l45hp3uhkqvrnptm I think you're wrong. It feels perfectly natural that the same activity can be used with different objects. That's the whole purpose of the Activity vocabulary itself being split between...
Phantasm · 4w
nostr:nprofile1qy2hwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnyd968gmewwp6kyqpqdf0nthpgzfmvxrzj0cfypmmt45l0y770j260auqhm3l45hp3uhkqvrnptm >And one thing that caught my attention is the use of Accept and Reject activities for managing approvals. This is an ActivityPub issue more than anything else. The "spec" is clear tha...
Uriel Fanelli (on Aktor) · 4w
nostr:nprofile1qy2hwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnyd968gmewwp6kyqpqdf0nthpgzfmvxrzj0cfypmmt45l0y770j260auqhm3l45hp3uhkqvrnptm the purpose of this madness is to force the whole fediverse to be "Mastodon". To me, developing Aktor,  I will decide that unspecified activities belong to type "gibberish" and create a...