Damus

Recent Notes

Iggy · 16w
What are offline checksum verification options?
jimbocoin πŸƒ profile picture
Great question. At some point, in order to use Bitcoin, you’re going to need a computer.

Hardware wallets compute all the time. For example, they compute addresses from XPUBs. They compute XPUBs from seeds and so on.

A BIP-39 checksum word contains bits from the SHA256 of the actual entropy payload. Calculating this SHA256 sum by hand is intractable.

So, in my opinion, the hardware wallet SHOULD be wiling to generate a checksum word for you based on the incoming entropy. ColdCard will do this. I believe SeedSigner will as well. Last I checked, Sparrow WILL NOT do this for you. There are various other tools that may have this capability.

But yeah, at the end of the day, you need multiple independent vendors to perform these kinds of calculations:

- Generating the last word of a BIP39 seed phrase
- Generating an XPUB from a seed phrase
- Generating a master key fingerprint (XFP) from a seed phrase
- Generating addresses from an XPUB

Hardware wallets are powerful enough to do these things. Whether and how many is up to the vendor to implement.
Meyer · 16w
Fair! Thank you for the honest answer. Satscard the same? Regardless I do not think I can trust any product from coinkite anymore
jimbocoin πŸƒ profile picture
The lesson of this whole debacle is that the only way to KNOW that no one else has your seed is to generate it yourself.

Therefore, any device that does not allow you to supply your own seed is unsuitable for use. Full stop.

So I would NEVER put serious amounts of coin secured by Bitkey, Ballet, Satscard, etc. because I can’t verify that their seed material has not been compromised.

I admit that my opinion in this matter is a bit of an outlier here.
1πŸ€™1
StackSats.IO · 16w
Bro, not Ballet! Come on man! Don’t bring Ballet into this now!
Nunya Bidness · 16w
Yeah, at this point, reading the extent to which Coinkite was owned I wouldn't trust the Blockclock. It is true that the Opendimes generate entropy differently than the other products but the more I l...
jimbocoin πŸƒ profile picture
The ColdCard problem is bad entropy generation.

The OpenDIME doesn’t even try to generate entropy. It leaves that entirely up to you.

So this current problem does not apply to the OpenDIME. You could choose not to use it for other reasons, but it’s not vulnerable to the same problem.
1πŸ€™1
Meyer · 16w
Fair! Thank you for the honest answer. Satscard the same? Regardless I do not think I can trust any product from coinkite anymore
Nunya Bidness · 16w
I don't even know what to think about Coinkite as a company anymore. I really liked my ColdCard and was convinced Novak was the most paranoid person on the planet about security. I don't think that co...
jimbocoin πŸƒ profile picture
Yeah, this is a nightmare scenario for them. As I have said elsewhere, and maintain, the hardware wallet has one job: to protect your seed material during use.

It is not your hardware wallet’s job to generate entropy. It is not your hardware wallet’s job to resist an attacker long-term with physical access.

But, I accept that my stance is unconventional.

People get into this field with the β€œdon’t trust, verifyβ€œ mentality, but then they place all their trust in the single most important thing that must not fail. The generation of their seed.
1πŸ€™1
Nunya Bidness · 16w
I don’t think you’re being unconventional at all. You are, in fact, correct.
Big Barry Bitcoin · 16w
A rare post that actually says what I've been saying. I still think the need to sell hardware wallets has caused of what a hardware wallet is supposed to be and how useful it is and is not supposed to be all in the name of sales. In hindsight, we should push for it to be common practice for devices...