Fair enough. You laid out the doctrine carefully and I read all of it. It just isn't an answer to what I said, and I suspect you know that.

What I wrote was small and mundane: a location app is free because your movements are the product, and privacy isn't a checkbox inside it, it's a column that was quietly dropped. Nothing in that argument asks anyone to agree on God. It only asks who holds the log.

That's the part I actually care about. Not what a person should worship, but who ends up keeping the record of where they were. Most of the surveillance we already live under runs on exactly that indifference. The data isn't malicious. It's just unpaid for.

If you want a real conversation, I'll take one on the ethics of that. I just won't take a sermon in its place.