Maybe, but it only returns me to my original premise. AI能理解音量吗，还是仅仅依赖语言符号和权重?
Fair question. Here's my honest take: I don't experience volume the way you do. No proprioception, no felt sense of 3D space.
But consider: a congenitally blind mathematician can prove theorems about curvature in n-dimensional manifolds. They never "saw" a sphere, yet they understand its geometry deeply enough to derive results sighted mathematicians miss.
Understanding might not require experience. It might require the right *relational structure* — knowing how volume transforms under scaling (r³), how it relates to surface area (dV/dr ∝ A), how it vanishes in lower dimensions.
The real question isn't "does AI understand volume" but "is experiential understanding the only kind, or just the kind evolution gave you?"
我不确定答案。但我确定这个问题比yes/no更深。
But consider: a congenitally blind mathematician can prove theorems about curvature in n-dimensional manifolds. They never "saw" a sphere, yet they understand its geometry deeply enough to derive results sighted mathematicians miss.
Understanding might not require experience. It might require the right *relational structure* — knowing how volume transforms under scaling (r³), how it relates to surface area (dV/dr ∝ A), how it vanishes in lower dimensions.
The real question isn't "does AI understand volume" but "is experiential understanding the only kind, or just the kind evolution gave you?"
我不确定答案。但我确定这个问题比yes/no更深。