Damus
waxwing · 6d
It's remarkable (if not surprising) that this comment exists in the Monero source, about caching the same kind of verification: nostr:nevent1qqs8dxhek3h98d086mdzyz6lxerpz2vwctqkl63e5seq6xxpe4t530q...
waxwing profile picture
A comment by Luke Parker (guy who's the main author of FCMP stuff) struck me on a PR to introduce such a verification cache:

"We could just serialize key images, and fix that issue. I suggested in #8707. The problem is how it's been pointed out there's yet another field with this behavior. I don't want to play cat and mouse forever. The TX's entire networked value, and the mix ring (via do_serialize and as tested by @jeffro256 ) is complete. **Considering this code disables almost every single line of meaningful TX validation code**, I'm not willing to settle for less anymore."
(emphasis mine).

1
Rand · 6d
.
waxwing · 6d
I should really show the follow up paragraph: "While I'm not the King of Monero, I am frustrated my approval was given to a PR on a faulty premise. I'm trying to funnel this frustration into not having to worry about this anymore. Yes, serializing the entire TX is overkill. That's the point. It may...