Damus
Lyn Alden profile picture
Lyn Alden
@LynAlden
Spam filters keep out things that 99.9% of people don’t want. Obvious attacks. Those attacks technically conform to the protocol but they are nonsense that nobody (including even the originator) cares about and that nobody is willing to pay for, and so they get blocked despite meeting technical consensus so they don’t disrupt node operations. They have no economic incentive to get into a block, and so they are easily filtered.

Filters are useful for nodes to remain economic against this type of random uneconomic nonsense.

But filters are ineffective against things that have a broad economic incentive, including subjective value.

If someone can get paid or otherwise subjectively desires to get an unusual transaction into a block that meets consensus rules, then they will.

A soft fork could block them (if such a fork could reach consensus), but node spam filters won’t block them.
124❤️14🤙17🚀2❤️1👀1💯1
Leurico8 · 114w
This idea of forking off humam stupidity is never gonna work.
LightningSpore · 114w
A soft fork could block them in their current form, but it would be very difficult to design a fork that could completely eliminate arbitrary data forever. Creative individuals (and degens) with open source code will do laps against people trying to build network consensus.
RealJohnDoe · 114w
$boost I think we could do a lot more to protect our precious #block space and #bandwidth. And that's what we must do. #Satoshi #Nakamoto is the only person with the right to put whatever he wants into the blockchain. #Nodes and miners serve at the pleasure of Bitcoin. Virtuous full nodes have a ...
Nyoro~n · 114w
I don't think anyone advocating for fixing filters expects to block all spam. Spam/arbitrary data will always be a part of Bitcoin and why OP_Return exists. Handling inscriptions (yet another method of storing arbitrary data in Bitcoin, certainly won't be the last) by subjecting to the same OP_Retur...
davide · 114w
Hashers, that is, people running “miner” appliances who choose to point them to pools that don’t use spam filters are contributing to letting through spam that 99.9 % of people don’t want and that could easily be throttled down if more of us pointed the said ASICs to pools that do apply spam...
Mukesh Siddh · 114w
hi 👋