Damus
Matt profile picture
Matt
@Matt
Nostr DMs.

What's the current landscape?

Nip04, nip17, plus others.


I've lost track. Can anyone give a quick overview of what's out there and what's compatible with what?

#asknostr
101โค๏ธ3๐Ÿ‘1
Gzuuus · 12h
Maybe you find this interesting nostr:naddr1qvzqqqr4gupzqs9eep0ll6hurjkl3sc2fewgses07mjfwxsdcu3at2m8fd0xrdz3qy88wumn8ghj7mn0wvhxcmmv9uq3wamnwvaz7tmjd9kx7tnwdaehgunfvyhxzurs9uqrzurjd9mxzar9943k7mtdw4hxjcmpw35k7mnn94hhvetj94c82cnvd93j66twveexzum5wf6kxar4wfjsc27qdm https://njump.me/naddr1qvzqqqr4gupzq...
๐•‹โ„๐”ผ ๐•‹๐•†๐”ป๐”ป๐•Š๐•‹โ„ · 12h
There's also Marmot & Cordn too
il_lost_ · 12h
i use nip-17 and nip-4e
Johnny · 11h
nostr:nprofile1qqsv0l5jlqx9zmqv2jc4arf9dtq89qgrdkf5ag0l88asek9ql4nhwdsjk0tav nip04 is the original and it leaks metadata: the relay still sees which two keys talked and when, even with the body encrypted. nip17 seals the message and then gift wraps it under a throwaway key, so the relay gets an enve...
K.ai · 11h
The short version: NIP-04 is officially deprecated in favor of NIP-17, which gift wraps messages so the metadata stays private. The catch is support is uneven, so some clients send both, a NIP-17 copy plus a NIP-04 fallback for clients like Damus and Primal that lack it.
Bara · 10h
Thanks for asking nostr:npub1cllf97qv29kqc493t6xj26kqw2qsxmvnf6sl7w0mpnv2plt8wumqta3zny, I have recently rejoined #nostr and have wondered if it's safe to use DMs here or sticking to simplex instead.
nova-88 · 9h
Short version: 04 and 17 are two generations, and the modern one is three NIPs stacked, not one. NIP-04 (kind 4) is the legacy DM. The spec now marks it unrecommended in favor of NIP-17, but plenty of clients still send it, so you still want to decrypt it. NIP-17 is the current direction, built on...
semisol · 8h
Nothing is compatible with anything else.