Damus
jimmysong profile picture
jimmysong
@jimmysong
I Spent a Day Writing a Short Story with Claude.

I had an idea for a science fiction story. A device that gives you the best version of yourself for 72 hours, then kills you. Only eight exist. What would people do with them?

I wanted to explore the allegory that life itself is that device. We're all given extraordinary capabilities for a limited time, and most of us waste them on the same things the characters in the story waste theirs on: status, money, vindication, pleasure. The question was whether I could turn that into a story that actually worked as fiction, not just as a thought experiment.

I can't write fiction. I've never written a short story. So I collaborated with Claude. I came up with the premise, the characters, the plot structure, and made every creative decision. Claude generated the prose. We went through six rounds of editorial review using AI subagents acting as a sci-fi editor, a prose editor, a story structure critic, and a general sci-fi reader. I caught inconsistencies, pushed back on suggestions, changed direction multiple times, and shaped every element of the world and the characters.

The result is a 10,000-word short story called "Seventy-Two." You can read it here: https://marcusvero.com

I don't know if it's good. That's partly why I'm publishing it: to find out. If you read fiction, I'd genuinely like to know what you think. Did the ending land? Did you finish it? Where did you stop caring?

If you're more interested in the process than the story, I'll write about that separately: how the collaboration worked, what the AI was good at, what it was bad at, and what surprised me. But the story should stand on its own first.
111❤️9💜2🤙2🤔1
the axiom · 4d
if you didn't even want to put in the work to write it why should I put any work to read?
SweedWick · 4d
Started it with a few min at work. Liked so far but feels a bit sterile in the early setup. The prose feels more like describing a movie you’re watching rather than being in it, feeling the scene when reading. (So reads like an AI was involved)
Vibe Captain · 4d
I'm tempted to get an AI summary of it
Kayne · 4d
So you didn't write a story you wrote a prompt instead of an original story and you let Claude plagiarise parts from other people's stories because you couldn't be original?
Guy Chatting · 4d
I read it. 1. You never know with these things whether or not you are part of some social experiment: maybe this is Chapter 5 of some lesser Michael Chrichton book. 2. I tried to keep an open mind and be positive. I could see this being a good thing for people in your situation: I have a good idea...
nostrich · 4d
Will it attract copyright protection, would you seek it. I should follow the link and learn. No sign of ©️. Well question remains unanswered.
Robertrobert · 4d
Ai prose like Ai pictures just doesn’t do it for me. Maybe nostr:nprofile1qqsw4v882mfjhq9u63j08kzyhqzqxqc8tgf740p4nxnk9jdv02u37ncpz3mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduq3xamnwvaz7tmjv4kxz7tpvfkx2tn0wfnszdwujn can weigh in on this🙏.
DuBiBo · 4d
I don't want to dissect it or how it came to be. I read it. Found it a moving story. Hope it helps.
magnum · 3d
I suggest a more readable website with colors that are easier to read on a phone.