idgi

no

dies this have anything to do with replies disappearing? or emojis falling out of replies?

yep

We use NIP22 comments on nostr:npub1xxdd8eusvdxmaph3fkuu9x2mymhrcc3ghe2l38zv0l4f4nqp659qskkt7a recipes, since those aren’t intended to show up in public feed threads, but I’m not sure I get why a kind 1 note shouldn’t also have a kind 1 reply. Wouldn’t that make reposting and quote-posting i...

I don't like how kind 1 is both a note and a reply

https://m.primal.net/MuQn.gif

Imagine being able to remove the 100 ifs for a reply only feed

NIP-22 already does this. It clearly says when replying to events that is not kind 1, then kind 1111 is to be used.

for what benefit?

Why

Clients can begin to offer a "quiet reply" mode that uses NIP-22. Users can opt-in to that when they don't want their reply to show up on their feeds to everybody (and accept that at least for now it might not show up for the thread author either). I would probably use it a lot.