When a government builds a national digital Identity system behind closed doors, you have to ask what they're so keen to hide.
BlackBeltBarrister has put together a thorough examination of the UK government's plans for a digital ID system, and the concerns are serious. An advisory group has been set up to oversee the programme, but its meetings, minutes, and budget are all kept secret. Journalists have been barred from attending their events. When MP Andrew Snowden submitted three written questions to the Cabinet Office about the group's budget and selection criteria, the Minister, James Frith, gave the same non-answer to all three. That's not accountability. That's a wall of silence dressed up in procedural language.
The government's defence is that the group is "merely advisory," so transparency doesn't apply. That's a nonsense argument, and anyone who has watched how policy gets shaped knows it. Advisory bodies influence decisions. They shape the direction of national programmes. If they didn't matter, the government wouldn't have assembled them.
Then there's the membership question. Some names have surfaced (David Rogers, Justine Roberts, Victor Dominello), but there are no published selection criteria. Were civil liberties groups invited? Were critics of government overreach given a seat at the table? We don't know, and that's precisely the problem.
The irony is thick. The UK GDPR exists to protect people's data and ensure transparency in how it's handled. Yet the very government tasked with upholding those principles is operating a digital Identity programme with near-zero openness. If this system is going to hold your Identity, your data, your access to services, then you deserve to know who's designing it, how they were chosen, and what they're deciding.
Public confidence doesn't come from secrecy. It comes from openness. If the government wants people to trust a national digital Identity system, they need to stop hiding and start being honest about what's being built in our name.
Full breakdown from BlackBeltBarrister here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi3G-xGyBEc#DigitalID #Privacy #Transparency #UKPolitics #DataProtection #GDPR #DigitalRights #SelfSovereignty #Accountability #CivilLiberties