Damus

Recent Notes

Luke Dashjr · 6d
BIP110 creates a rare opportunity for bitcoiners we should take advantage of: Unlike most consensus changes, it is extremely simple: with only 5 modified lines of code and 72 added, across 5 source c...
AJ2884 profile picture
I don't think I've heard anyone argue that it's BIP110's code complexity that's the problem, it's what changing the code does or could do that people have issues with. A single lines change could easily have procedural, cultural, and game theory changes, both known and expected, and unknown and unexpected.
1❤️1💯1
Cykros · 5d
Honestly it's not that it does too much. It's that it doesn't solve anything. At all. And yea, it COULD have negative downsides. I actually don't think there'd be much. But when it accomplishes nothing why risk any?
Jack K · 1w
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_identity Do I literally need to go make 2 onchain transactions (SegWit / non SegWit) to show that 1 sat ≠ 1 sat and 1 bit ≠ 1 bit despite both transactions in...
AJ2884 profile picture
From my perspective, you seem to be preaching ideology to a bunch of pragmatists. (Well, we're pretty ideological too but... 🙂)

I admittedly don't know much for details about what you're talking about (I'm assuming it boils down to your efforts to define the value of a sat in terms of energy, and so changing the number of sets that can be processed per block changes that value but...) , but to me it sounds like you're very roughly arguing that we should only do things the way Grandpa did, because if we don't then we're disrespecting Grandpa.

One of the things that I always struggled with about the energy sat value work is that since there were/are many thoughtfully selected yet fundamentally arbitrary choices within the Bitcoin protocol, while some of the larger, broader implementation agnostic sat/energy takeaways quite possibly have some deeper truth to them, many of the specific calculations and conclusions will be somewhat arbitrary artifacts of the specific values of the random decisions that were made along the way within the development and implementation of the protocol. And perhaps the same could be said about many of the constants of nature, perhaps being fine-tuned yet fundamentally arbitrary, but the mere fact that we don't discuss the communities appetite for changing G, C, etc., or see seemingly arbitrary step functions in any of their values, implies that they very much are fundamentally different.
1
Jack K · 1w
I’m really arguing that nobody understands the protocol Satoshi gave us nor the constants he defined in fiat. This is not a matter of opinion, you think you can change the parameters after they have been set, you need humility to understand why not to. The fees must always be paid, we have diverte...
HODL · 2w
I never understand this thing people do where they go “my parents never taught me that, so that’s why I don’t know it.” Like you’re an adult now. Teach it to yourself? I guess I do under...
AJ2884 profile picture
A friend once told me that his teeth were bad because he wasn't taught to brush them (I think he started brushing in his 20s).

I sometimes wonder what it's going to be like for the masses when Neuralink or the like let them see what it's like to, kind of just by default, think for yourself, try, and have agency.
HODL · 2w
I had a life realization during Covid that I was done extending politeness to anyone who didn’t display politeness One example: I had a heavy shopping cart packed to the brim with groceries during...
AJ2884 profile picture
Yeah, I feel like, for most of my life, society was set up so that people in power could take advantage of the masses, and in exchange, the masses could enjoy simple, thoughtless lives. And it was all retarded bullshit and lies, but at least it was convenient and had an heir of respectability. But then the people in power broke their promise, things got complicated, inconvenient, and they stopped pretending to respect the masses, and I lost my motivation to pretend to not be a bad person by their completely incoherent and self-sabotaging standards.
❤️1💙1