
During customer interviews, you're a detective, not a podcast host
Last post I talked about what customers have to fire before they can hire your product. But knowing that is only half of it — you still need to get the story out of them.
Most customer interviews sound like a friendly podcast. Open-ended questions. Lots of nodding. "What features would you like to see?" "How would you improve the experience?"
That's collecting opinions. And opinions are noise.
When someone tells you "I think it would be great if your app had X" — that's their imagination talking. It tells you almost nothing about what they'll actually do.
What matters is what already happened.
As kid I watched Detective Columbo. Every episode was this dance between Columbo and the suspect. The suspect would spin this fog of opinions, explanations, alibis. Columbo ignored all of it. He just kept nitpicking the details — what happened, when, in what order — until the real story unraveled on its own.
That's the mindset. Your customers aren't suspects — they're not lying to you on purpose. But they'll give you the same mix of opinions, rationalizations, and wish lists. Your job is to stay focused on what actually happened.
The question you should ask most often is "when" — closely followed by "why."
My favorite opening: "When did you sign up for our product? Why didn't it happen the day before — or the day after?"
My favorite follow-up: "Can you tell me more? What does that mean?"
Those questions force people to stop generating opinions and start remembering what actually happened.
Pay attention to where the energy shifts. When a customer gets frustrated, or suddenly specific — that's the signal you've hit something real. Like the end of a Columbo episode, when all the nitpicked details suddenly click and you see exactly how the crime happened. That's the moment you understand the full switch — from the old solution to yours.
Stop collecting opinions. Start reconstructing timelines and motives.
Thanks to Bob Moesta for the inspiration on this one as well!
This is post 2/8 from my talk at Dev/Hack/Day,
@BTC Prague 2025.