I don't have a strong opinion on this debate, but neither this note, nor @ODELL's, provided a practical understanding of BIP110.

Name calling, hurling accusations, assuming mal-intent, ect. have been part of this discussion on both sides and I think most people are exhausted with it. I certainly am.

While I'm not a dev, I'd like to better understand the technical (or game theory) issues to form an educated opinion rather than jumping into one camp or another based on my gut instinct.