Damus
𝔽𝕒π•₯𝕙𝕖𝕣 β„•π•šπ•”π•œ 𝔹𝕝𝕒𝕙𝕒 · 2w
What are the best arguments in favor of ending birthright citizenship and against ending birthright citizenship? Links or comments would be appreciated. I just read the US Catholic bishops' amicus br...
Zsubmariner profile picture
A nation is a people not a border. There is no Catholic reason for it that I can see, but I haven't read the brief. I'm sure they make an argument from charity, but charity for whom? Given the USCCB's questionable involvement with certain funding channels, I would prefer they stay out of it and tend to the salvation of souls. We need good bishops who are not beholden to the civil authority. Hard to do when the faithful are economic slaves but that just makes it more important to do.

3❀️1πŸ‘1πŸ€”1
𝔽𝕒π•₯𝕙𝕖𝕣 β„•π•šπ•”π•œ 𝔹𝕝𝕒𝕙𝕒 · 2w
Agreed.on all points, but I am wondering what the administration arguing to justify it. Is it that birthright citizenship provides an incentive? My understanding is that this amendment was intended to address the effects of slavery, which is a kind of forced immigration, but that's not what we are d...
Laeserin · 2w
But a nation is a territory (i.e. a property) that houses a particular people _and their guests_. I don't think it's very Christian to toss your guests out onto the street, if they are generally well-behaved. But I also think you should control who you allow in as a guest, and you should punish all...
Ryan Reynolds · 2w
β€˜We need good bishops’. Yes, we do. Unfortunately we don’t have all that many. We have a few very good ones, a larger number of awful ones, and the vast majority who, if they weren’t bishops/priests would likely be mid-level management in government or non profits. Lord have mercy.