Damus
Artemis · 14w
Another weird thing about this section on ethnic minorities in Iran & the human rights abuses they face. On page 2 of the book, in the introduction, Benjamin opens a paragraph: "Iranians, we learne...
Artemis profile picture
Later in the same paragraph she says "Yes, they are Muslims, & overwhelmingly Shia Muslims, but they celebrate ancient Zoroastrian holidays—to the dismay of conservative clerics."

This paragraph is describing "Iranians," & she says "they are Muslims" as though that can be said as a blanket statement. Not "x percent are Muslim", not "the majority are Muslim."

To get grammatical for a second, the antecedent of "they" here is "Iranians". She just said "Iranians are Muslims."

Hmm.
1
Artemis · 14w
So, on page 2, Medea Benjamin introduces a definition of what it means to be Iranian that is both ethnically & religiously specific: Iranians are Persian & Muslim. If I didn't believe that she got paid (or otherwise incentivized) to write this shit, I'd just think she was a very bad & small-minded ...