@nprofile1q... @nprofile1q... I particularly winced at
"This has resulted in (understandable) backlash against advances in AI that range from various types of enclosure to simply not sharing at all."
No, no, no. If you're using the metaphor of creative "commons" then you should be very deliberate about how you use the word "enclosure".
Me defending my stuff against AI scraping is not 'enclosure'. It is the AI companies who are doing the modern enclosure of the commons, trying to use LLMs to hoover up all the currently commonly held goods and turn them into a private resource that they control access to.
(With the same government support as in the 17th century and the same sort of argument - because otherwise the new industry would not be viable.)