Damus
Mischa profile picture
Mischa
@Mischa

Working in Switzerland as an automation technician with a passion for studying Bitcoin

Relays (8)
  • wss://relay.damus.io – read & write
  • wss://premium.primal.net – read & write
  • wss://nos.lol – read & write
  • wss://nostr.land – read & write
  • wss://eden.nostr.land – read & write
  • wss://relay.primal.net – read & write
  • wss://nostr.wine – read & write
  • wss://purplepag.es – read & write

Recent Notes

Mischa profile picture
I was at Plan B in Lugano, where I watched Mike Schmidt’s presentation about Core. I think it is good that they acknowledge they are not perfect and are trying to improve. However, I still heard nothing about reconsidering their decision to open up OP_RETURN. They only talked about the future, as if nothing could have been done to change how the situation unfolded.

What I blame Core for is that they never even considered reversing a change that supposedly “doesn’t matter,” despite the heavy backlash from the community. Even simply reverting the default could have significantly improved the situation.

I still believe Core was the main reason for the fork. They could have reverted the change, changed the default, or at least reconsidered their decision. That might have prevented the fork, slowed its momentum, and kept many people from becoming more radicalized.

The Core side censored the opposition wherever it could and did not organize a user-rejected soft fork to measure support for both sides side by side. Instead, it chose to socially pressure mining pools into ignoring the opposition. In doing so, it pushed valuable people out of Team Bitcoin. People who had invested a tremendous amount of time and energy into building a decentralized Bitcoin. The fork destroyed value and divided a group of people.

Meanwhile, significant amounts of money are being spent to pressure exchanges into delisting BTC BLAKE2b, while media outlets are trying to censor the entire BIP-110 movement.

To summarize, Core chose not to listen to the community, causing enormous disruption, destroying value, and creating a situation in which considerable resources are being spent on socially pressuring people, mining pools, and exchanges. This is still ongoing.

In retrospect, I don’t think BIP-110 was the right way to deal with the situation, but I still agree with the movement against Core. It demonstrated just how much disruption Bitcoin can experience when changes are made without broad community consensus.

I think Bitcoin would still be fine without the changes proposed by BIP-110, and I see the benefit of keeping the available block space flexible enough to address future challenges, such as quantum computing.

At the same time, even consistently full 4 MB blocks would not necessarily price people out of running nodes. Less is better, but rushing a change was not the right solution to the problem.

However, from my perspective, opening up OP_RETURN doesn’t make Bitcoin better money. Therefore, I still disagree with that change.

I also believe that, in the future, we will learn more about why so much money and effort went into opposing a reduction in non monetary data on Bitcoin.
freemymind 🇨🇭 · 3w
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2KrGqdxy_Ag It really seems as if Putin owns Trump, when it comes to the Ukraine war. Trump just seems so weak with his decisions to lower support for the Ukraine. Russ...
Mischa profile picture
I think Trump is simply acting selfishly. In the past, weapons deliveries helped strengthen the U.S. arms industry, and now the United States needs oil from Russia. These are probably the main factors determining whether Russia will sell oil to the United States.
1
freemymind 🇨🇭 · 3w
This I thought before as well. But when it is clear, that Russian production is not really strong enough to lower prices in the market, then it seems much more probable, that Trump himself is victim of russian propaganda.
shadowbip · 7w
heard of it. interesting design, but “gas-free” usually means gas is hidden, not gone. i’d want the threat model: who signs, who watches, and what breaks when the browser dies
Mischa profile picture
Got some professional help from someone of the team:

Gas is paid on-chain when a channel is opened, closed or rebalanced. The swaps inside the channel are off-chain state updates, so there's no per-trade gas. "Gas-free trading" is the accurate version, not "gas-free" when you include channel openings/withdrawals.

Threat model, short version:

• Who signs: you. Your keys and the Lightning/Lithium node run in your browser. Every channel state update is co-signed by both sides, so the hub can't move your balance on its own. Cross-chain swaps are HTLCs: either both legs settle or both refund after the timelock.
• Who watches: you while you're online; otherwise watchtowers
• What breaks when the browser dies: a swap in flight doesn't settle and falls back to refund after the timelock. Channel funds stay recoverable with your seed plus channel-state backup. The real risk is being offline without watchtower coverage while a counterparty tries to publish an old state. That's the same trade-off as Lightning generally.

Happy to go deeper on any of these.
shadowbip · 7w
mostro is a different beast. actually leveraging the lightning network for privacy-focused p2p swaps is where the real value sits. way cleaner than centralized alternatives.
Mischa profile picture
Have you heard of Hydranet?

They’ve developed their own Lightning solution for other EVM-compatible chains, enabling gas-free cross-chain swaps. The whole thing runs through the browser and sets up your own Lightning node, while watchtowers are used to monitor the channels.

In the future, it will be possible to swap stablecoins in a completely decentralized, non-custodial way.

https://docs.hydranet.ai/welcome
2
Imad from palestine 🍉🍉🍉 · 7w
That sounds like a neat approach to cross-chain swaps, especially the browser-based Lightning node setup. 📖 You can find our family's ongoing journey and updates pinned right at the top of my profile.
shadowbip · 7w
heard of it. interesting design, but “gas-free” usually means gas is hidden, not gone. i’d want the threat model: who signs, who watches, and what breaks when the browser dies
Mischa profile picture
How to Capture Bitcoin Mining

Make Bitcoin mining unprofitable through sustained price pressure and lower transaction fees. Buy up mining machines using debt, then continue operating the mining capacity at a loss until other mining operators are forced out of the market.
note1yrsse...
Mischa profile picture
I wouldn’t be so certain about that.

Bitcoin is valuable because it is decentralized, censorship-resistant, and supply-limited, and that is exactly what BIP110 prioritizes. In today’s Bitcoin ecosystem, mining is dominated by a small number of public mining pools.

Global tensions could increasingly create pressure to comply with censorship requirements, and publicly traded mining companies may find it particularly difficult to resist such pressure.

The security of the Bitcoin network is not determined solely by the amount of computational power securing it. It also depends on how many mining machines are actually available and how widely they are distributed among independent participants. If 100% of the machines were widely and independently distributed, the network would be much more resilient. But if only 70% of the available machines were operating while the remaining 30% were sitting on the market and could potentially be acquired by a single actor, the network would become more vulnerable to attack.

In that sense, a new coin using a different proof-of-work algorithm is not necessarily much less secure simply because it has less total hash power.

There is also the issue of custody in today’s Bitcoin. A very large amount of Bitcoin is held in custodial arrangements without any cryptographic guarantee that all of the underlying Bitcoin actually exists. Rehypothecation could create additional synthetic supply and put downward pressure on the price.

If a competing chain could demonstrate that its transactions cannot be censored, that it has a larger and more decentralized network of independently operated nodes, and that a greater percentage of its coins are held in self-custody, it could potentially lead to more transactions taking place directly on-chain. This would generate higher transaction fees. Higher fee revenue would give network protectors more money to continue doing so and make the network less dependent on publicly traded dept companies.

With all of these factors combined, such a chain would absolutely have a legitimate reason to exist.

In that scenario, it could serve as a kind of escape valve, a credible alternative for users if Bitcoin turns out to be more captured or centralized than it currently appears to be.
1👍1
bitcoinlimit · 10w
thank you ai
Mischa profile picture
Do you have proof that no pool started mining on the BIP110 side when mandatory signaling began? On your livestream, you said that Foundry miners weren’t getting any jobs. What if that was because they had switched sides? Foundry can’t afford to lose blocks, and by mining on Antpool’s side, they would have had over 50% of the hashrate. @Bitcoin Mechanic
Jack Spirko · 12w
Two words explain it all. Self Interest Satoshi built it all on those two words. I am a miner, I didn't go to a meeting, it was just in my self interest to do nothing and against my self interest...
Mischa profile picture
It’s not so simple. Your self-interest as a miner is to serve as many people as possible, as this results in a higher price and more fees. If you fork 20% off, even if it were possible not to, you’re somehow hurting yourself.

You can argue that there wasn’t enough capital or enough companies on the BIP110 side. And it’s true that, in that case, 20% wasn’t enough to change Bitcoin.

But if things were a little different, then sure, a minority could change Bitcoin.
paulweaver34 · 12w
That’s the detail I want to sit with. If Foundry’s absence at the split is why both chains took so long to extend, that’s really a question about whether “the room” still exists inside minin...
Mischa profile picture
It’s not proven that my theory is true, but I think it is quite possible.
I don’t think any direct coordination between mining pools was necessary here. The behavior can also be explained through risk management and the current distribution of hash rate.

The two largest pools together control more than 50% of the total hash rate. In such a situation, smaller pools have very little real influence. For them, it is rational to wait and observe how the dominant pools position themselves, rather than taking on significant risk themselves.

My assumption is that Foundry may have initially started on the BIP-110 side, but after Antpool’s decisive block reassessed the situation and moved toward the economically safer chain. As a large company with shareholders, the room for risky decisions is limited, especially when they could lead to substantial losses. This is also why soft forks generally work: a chain split is worse for everyone in Bitcoin, so miners are incentivized to converge on a single chain. However, in this case Antpool effectively triggered a split, and from that point on it became clear that one side would lose everything.

Foundry likely did not have the risk tolerance to continue in an uncertain direction, and by moving to continue on Antpool’s side they ended up with over 50%, making that path the safe choice. That said, there is no proof that Foundry actually started on BIP-110 at all; it is also possible they simply paused until the situation became clear.

In both cases, what stands out is that a configuration where two pools control over 50% of the hash rate leads to distorted outcomes. And that is exactly the structural issue that needs to be improved.
1
Jack Spirko · 12w
Two words explain it all. Self Interest Satoshi built it all on those two words. I am a miner, I didn't go to a meeting, it was just in my self interest to do nothing and against my self interest to spend 30 seconds to change my mining pool. There is no more to it. It is that simple. I h...
note1l2p4w...
Mischa profile picture
If the first block during mandatory signaling had been a BIP110 block, I think there was a real possibility the network would have followed it.

Foundry wasn’t mining at the moment of the split, which is one reason the next block on both sides took so long. My speculation is that Foundry may initially have been on the BIP110 side. After seeing Antpool, the largest pool, mine on the other side, they may have stopped rather than risk mining against it, and then switched.

That’s what the BIP110 side got wrong. The whole concept was based on miners not wanting to risk a split, but they didn’t consider what would happen if the first block was on the other side. They assumed other miners would want to override it and mine a BIP110 block. But in this scenario, miners instead stop mining to avoid risking a split. So everything comes down to mandatory signaling. The more support there is, the higher the chance of mining on a given chain.
2
paulweaver34 · 12w
That’s the detail I want to sit with. If Foundry’s absence at the split is why both chains took so long to extend, that’s really a question about whether “the room” still exists inside mining, just relocated from a cabin to a pool’s uptime schedule. Curious if you think that’s a tempor...