💯 I agree with everything you’ve written. The risk being in whoever terminates the traffic was my biggest concern from the get go of FIPS being mentioned for the very first time on nostr (roughly 9 months ago).
My honeypot worries was because this was the MOST impressively designed protocol which I have probably ever seen. For alpha software it was amazingly well specified. This thing came out of nowhere and holy moly I couldn’t find anything about the dev except he contributed to whitenoise.
Justin Moon was singing its praises and I was genuinely intrigued and excited and worried all at once if something was being touted as the “new” internet. I asked a couple of questions and got no replies from Justin. I think I even dug up an old twitter account to ask him there. Nada.
Guess that just fuelled the paranoia as I mentioned earlier; I am overtly paranoid 😅
I did a sloppy Joe special audit of it and there were some things which scared me. Sybil root attack and Transitive Trust being the most. But being that was alpha, I’m guessing those things are of no concern now?
Also find it kinda funny that the people with the biggest brains on nostr and the planet get riled up af when I mention any negative or curious insight into FIPS.
Is this going to become the new Internet? Or is it like a tailnet with only devices you explicitly trust? (Those you own) or is it a hybrid?
Sorry to be a pain in the ass but I legit thank you for the time you take to explain stuff.