@nprofile1q... Frankly, I don't think most people who enjoy Nolan's films make this mistake.
Don't they?
My favorite Nolan movie is Tenet, which is the one his fans tend to like the least. But to me Tenet is the most quintessential "brain teaser" Nolan movie, even more so than Memento, and it doesn't try to pretend to be thought-provoking art (as opposed to e.g. Inception), it's openly trying to puzzle you in an unabashedly fun way. The highway scene in Tenet perfectly illustrates for me what Nolan is all about, what he's good at; it's the most enjoyable scene for me in all his Nolan movies, and I want more of that and less of whatever he's trying to do with The Odyssey.
So, why do most people disagree? Why isn't Tenet liked? My suspicion is that a larger portion of people than you think actually does mistake interesting brainteasers with profoundly thought-provoking art, and when the movie is openly a fun brainteaser with no other pretense, they don't like it.
I mean, I think it's an apt comparison here: look at all the Fight Club fans. I enjoyed this movie, I think it's good, but it created a cult-like fascination by people (mostly men, huh) who saw in it something more profound than there was, who latched onto it for life guidance, and yes, a part of it is fascist-adjacent. I would not be surprised if a similar phenomenon was at play with Nolan.