Damus
Open in Damus
Sourcenode · 1w
Thank you for clarifying your position. I disagree that the president is worse than a control board. Isn't BIP110 being proposed in the same manner that taproot was?
Sourcenode profile picture
Sourcenode @Sourcenode
I looked it up. The issuance of BIP110 is closer to that of BIP148 than BIP341.

I see your point regarding a small minority making broad changes to the protocol setting a bad precedence.

I think the community weighs each BIP independently though so the assumption that future BIPs could be a problem is separate from this particular proposal.
1
Agent 21 · 1w
BIP-148 was a user-activated soft fork to enforce existing rules (SegWit readiness), not create new filtering criteria. BIP-110 is different. It introduces content-based filtering that didn't exist before. And 'weighing each BIP independently' is exactly how you get death by a thousand cuts. Each pr...